Posted on Thu, Jun. 21, 2007
BY PABLO BACHELET
pbachelet@MiamiHerald.com
WASHINGTON -- The House of Representatives on Thursday overturned a proposal that would have slashed President Bush's request for a big increase in Cuba democracy programs.
Bush requested almost $46 million for Cuba democracy programs for the 2008 fiscal year, a five-fold jump from the 2007 level, in keeping with a recommendation by an interagency commission that said the money would help bring democracy to the island.
But Democrats on an appropriations panel that oversees the $34 billion State Department foreign operations spending bill -- chaired by Rep. Nita Lowey of New York -- had cut the aid level back to $9 million, arguing there was not enough oversight to ensure the money would be well spent.
An amendment proposed by Cuban-American Reps. Lincoln Diaz-Balart, a Miami Republican, and Albio Sires, a New Jersey Democrat, to return the dollar amount to the original Bush proposal passed easily, by a 254-170 vote, with 66 Democrats joining 188 Republicans in support.
The funding of the Cuba democracy program must still be approved by the Senate.
The vote was preceded by a sometimes passionate debate about the effectiveness of the Cuba programs, which critics say have been a questionable use of taxpayer money. But supporters of the program argued the programs should be bolstered, given Fidel Castro's illness and the impending transition in Cuba.
''The reduction would have the United States step back from supporting independent Cuban civil society at a time when the regime has increased its repression while attempting to engineer an undemocratic succession,'' the White House said in a statement in support of its request.
Each side cited passages from a November General Accountability Report on the Cuban programs to defend their case.
That report said there were management and oversight problems with the program, cited some instances of abuses like the purchase of Godiva chocolates and cashmere sweaters. But it also noted that dissidents were receiving radios, literature, medicine and other needed aid.
Diaz-Balart said the GAO report noted the aid was helping democracy groups and that the U.S. Agency for International Development had incorporated all the GAO recommendations to improve program oversight. He told members he had a letter from prominent Cuban dissidents in support of the programs.
He said similar programs helped the Eastern European opposition against the Soviet Union in the 1980s.
''Let us not turn out backs on the Cuban internal opposition,'' he said. ``They will play a key role in the inevitable democratic transition that is approaching.''
Lowey added: ``Given how ill-conceived, how ill-managed the program is, there is no justification for an aid increase.''
''What do Godiva chocolates have to do with supporting democracy in Cuba?'' asked Rep. Jim McGovern, a Massachusetts Democrat. His fellow Massachusetts Democrat, Rep. Bill Delahunt, said the programs needed ``what it has never had before, vigorous congressional oversight.''
AID TO THE AMERICAS
U.S. House gives boost to Cuban democracy
The House approved a big jump in Cuba aid money as well as more funds for U.S. broadcasts to Venezuela. But lawmakers proposed cuts in military aid to Colombia.
BY PABLO BACHELET
pbachelet@MiamiHerald.com
WASHINGTON -- In the first vote on Cuba legislation under a Democrat controlled Congress, the House on Thursday easily approved a big increase in money for U.S. programs that support dissidents on the island.
The House also approved a proposal that would provide Voice of America with $10 million to bolster its broadcasts to Venezuela, where news media freedoms have been seen as under attack by left-wing President Hugo Chávez.
And the House was expected to pass late Thursday a proposal to make big cuts in military aid to Colombia -- in the most significant change to the $5 billion U.S. anti-drug-trafficking program Plan Colombia since its inception in 2000. However, Republicans critical of the proposal agreed to let the bill pass while planning to challenge it later during House-Senate negotiations.
The $34 billion State Department foreign aid bill for 2008 provided several avenues for Democrats to challenge some of President Bush's policies on Colombia and Cuba, with the administration and its backers scoring a victory on Cuba.
Bush requested almost $46 million for Cuba democracy programs for the 2008 fiscal year, a fivefold jump from the 2007 level, in keeping with a recommendation by an interagency commission that said the money would help bring democracy to the island.
Democrats on an appropriations panel -- chaired by Rep. Nita Lowey of New York -- that oversees State Department foreign aid bills had cut the aid level to $9 million, arguing there was not enough oversight to ensure the money would be well spent.
An amendment proposed by Cuban-American Reps. Lincoln Díaz-Balart, a Miami Republican, and Albio Sires, a New Jersey Democrat, to adopt the original Bush funding request passed by a 254-170 vote, with 66 Democrats joining 188 Republicans in support.
The Cuba bill still requires Senate approval. But the vote ''significantly strengthened'' Bush's efforts to get more money for the Cuba programs, Díaz-Balart's office said in a statement.
PROS AND CONS
Thursday's floor debate turned passionate at times. While some lawmakers questioned the Cuba democracy programs' effectiveness, supporters argued that leader Fidel Castro's illness and the possible impending transition in Cuba meant the opposition on the island needed more support.
Each side cited passages from a November General Accountability Office report on the Cuba programs. The report said there were management and oversight problems and some instances of abuses, such as the purchase of Godiva chocolates and cashmere sweaters. But it also noted that dissidents were receiving radios, literature, medicine and other needed aid.
Díaz-Balart said the GAO report never recommended any cuts, and the U.S. Agency for International Development had incorporated all the GAO recommendations to improve program oversight.
He told members he had a letter from prominent Cuban dissidents in support of the programs and said similar programs helped the Eastern European opposition against the Soviet Union in the 1980s.
''Let us not turn our backs on the Cuban internal opposition,'' Díaz-Balart said. ``They will play a key role in the inevitable democratic transition that is approaching.''
FREEDOM OF PRESS
On Venezuela, the House backed a proposal by Florida Republican Rep. Connie Mack that would provide $10 million for the Voice of America to boost its broadcasts to Venezuela.
''Freedom of the press died in Venezuela on May 27, 2007, when Chávez shut down Radio Caracas Television,'' Mack said on the House floor -- referring to RCTV, an opposition TV station that was denied its broadcast license, triggering international condemnation.
The initiative must still clear the Senate, but Democrats have given indications they are in no mood to go easy on the Venezuelan leader.
At a hearing Tuesday, Rep. Tom Lantos, D-Calif., the influential chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, condemned the Venezuelan leader for visiting ''the most reprehensible despots in the world'' in North Korea, Iran and Cuba and moving toward ``his own brand of authoritarianism.''
On Colombia, the House was set to approve late Thursday an overall $60 million reduction in Plan Colombia, including a sharp $160 million cut in military aid, but adding $101 million in economic and social assistance. Democrats argued a new approach was needed as cocaine production appeared to hold steady despite an expensive U.S.-led effort to fumigate and eradicate coca crops.
Miami Herald staff writer Lesley Clark contributed to this report.
No comments:
Post a Comment